Thursday, September 10, 2009

Is Krishna Real

Recently there has been an article by Dr. Manish Pandit in lots of news paper, wherein he put forward his argument in support of the existence of Krishna & actual dating of the Mahabharata war. He has based his research on the basis of various astrological references that are found in the Mahabharata Epic. Going by those references the date arrived at is around 3067 BC for that epic war. This is a 5000 years old event & no doubt we dont find any other physical proof of that history other then the names of various places (like Hastinapur, Gandhar, Dwarka etc.) which from our current knowledge & continuing traditions know are there.

So the point is that when we talk of any thing which is separated from our current age by thousands of years, then the basis of verifying them should be your living & continuous traditions as against the physical proofs. By the same means, we can then establish that maybe Ramayan is also not a plain moral story, but a great collection of history which happenned thousands of years before even the Mahabharata happenned.

Let me briefly mention here about the concept of dimensions. Till about 100 years back, humans were only aware of 3 dimensions in universe which is length, breadth & height. I would say even till today 99% of us are only aware of this 3 dimensions in the universe. But let me tell you that the scientific world now readily accept the fourth dimension as well & that is the dimension of Time-Space. This came out after Einstein proposed his Special Theory of relativity & General theory of relativity. Over the decades, with numerous experiments done over by the scientists all over the world, the fourth dimension is now a very much accepted phenomenon. As you see, even time is one of the dimension. As we can move freely from one point to the other in the generally accepted 3 dimensions of the world, so too we can freely move in time (atleast theoretically this is found to be possible as per general theory of relativity). Maybe in future, the human race will be so developed so as to actually start moving in time & then maybe we would be actually able to verify all our historical facts without any bias. Till that time, we need to rely on our living traditions & take them as a proxy to this fourth Time-Space dimension & trust them on the facts as said by them about Ramayana, Mahabharata etc.

2 comments:

  1. We human beings are strange beings. Over time history blends into folk lore and folk lore into mythology. Our inability to seperate facts from our perception of them doesn't cease to amaze me.

    As for the existance of a historical Krishna, the maternal uncle to the 5 sons of Pandu and the person present during the war of Mahabharata there is no doubt. There must have existed a historical charachtor by that name who has inspired folk lore which over time turned into legend which metamorphosized into the mythological god like being of today.

    The existance of a child in a village called gokul who was standing in a cave under the govardhan mountain during a heavy dounpour with his family and relatives I do not Question what i doubt is, was it the child holding the mountain with his little finger or was it the child able to reach the roof of the cave only with one finger which was being held up by the adults present.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Intersting to know that the debate would be endless.

    ReplyDelete